Speak Out: Missouri: A Southern State

Posted by mobushwhacker on Mon, Jul 18, 2011, at 12:22 PM:

I was recently asked to write a brief summary of Missouri History, Heritage and Culture for the Southern Nationalist News. The original story was published at:http://southernnationalist.com/blog/2011/07/06/the-southern-state-of-missouri/

I was recently asked to give a brief description of Missouri, its culture and its heritage. This is no easy task. Often described as a "Border State," the majority of Missouri finds itself in the Midwest, yet it is anchored to the South by the Southeast portion of the state known as "the Boot-heel," a place where Missouri is tied to the South both physically and culturally.

Southeast Missourian blogger James Baughn, describes Missouri's "anchor to the South" (in an August 16, 2010 entry) in the following words:

"The town of Belmont, in Mississippi County southeast of Charleston, is served by its own paved state highway. Too bad nobody lives there.

Belmont, once an important river landing and the home to a Civil War [sic] battle, isn't even shown on most modern maps. It's easy to find, though. Take I-55 south to Highway 80, turn east, and keep going until the pavement ends. You'll come to a dead-end sign, a rare sight for a major state highway.

...Throughout most of its history, Belmont has had a ferry boat connecting to Columbus, Kentucky. The ferry is long gone, but the highways on either side -- both numbered Highway 80 -- still remain.

...If the ferry was still operating, it would be possible to enter Kentucky and follow the highway across the entire length of the state and into Virginia. Indeed, Highway 80 is the longest state highway in Kentucky, providing a continuous connection -- minus the ferry -- between Missouri and Virginia."

Opposite of Belmont is Columbus Kentucky, where the Confederates built their "Gibraltar of the West" a place in which Kentucky was literally anchored to Missouri by a huge chain to help prevent Union gunboats from controlling the Mississippi River. Belmont, Missouri was also the site of a battle where Missouri State Guard General M. Jeff Thompson defeated Ulysses S. Grant.

Missouri was first controlled by the Spanish, then the French. It was Jefferson who obtained Missouri through the Louisiana Purchase. Once this transpired it opened the flood gate for the Scots-Irish settlers of Virginia, Kentucky, North Carolina and Tennessee to pursue their restless spirits and forge out a better life in new lands.

These settlers defined Missouri culturally as a Southern state, a sister to the Deep South by proxy.

Prior to the German revolution, the German population was relatively small compared to the Scots-Irish settlers who had crossed the Appalachians to get here.

Wikipedia states that; "The Naturalist Gottfried Duden, a German attorney, settled on the north side of the Missouri River along Lake Creek in 1824. He was investigating the possibilities of settlement in the area by his countrymen. In 1827 he returned to Germany, which he felt was overpopulated. There in 1829 he published Bericht über eine Reise nach den westlichen Staaten Nordamerikas (Journal of a trip to the western states of North America), extolling the attractions of Missouri."

The publication of this book would later have drastic consequences for the Scots-Irish Southerners of Missouri. The relatively small German population carved out their own "Rhineland" of Eastern Missouri, they chose the areas of the state that had the poorest land, bad for traditional agriculture production but good for planting vineyards, a Missouri Rhineland if you will, that roughly speaking can be traced from St. Louis west, to just east of Jefferson City.

North of the Missouri River, the soil was suitable for plantation agriculture and the area is still known today as "Little Dixie.

The Western Border of Missouri as defined by the late author Patrick Brophy is as follows: "The Missouri -- Kansas border is no ordinary state line. For longer than any other it was the Border with a Capital "B," the would-be "permanent frontier" between Western Civilisation and the Stone Age. For a decade it was the battle-line between North and South."

Brophy continues by stating that Missouri's frontier "had a sectional character of its own... and had extremely close ties with the South. Up to the third decade of the century anywhere along the frontier, New Englanders remained small islands in a sea of Southern folk... an uneasy blend of the old, aristocratic Tidewater and the raw "rugged-individualist" Scotch-Irish world of the Appalachian backwoods."

Thus was the case in Northeast Missouri and Northwest Missouri as well and like New Englanders, the Germans remained small islands "in a sea of Southern folk," that is until the German revolution of 1848 - a Marxist revolution in which the losers fled to America, specifically, Missouri, to the "Missouri Rhineland" thanks to Mr. Gottfried Dudden's book.

By the time of the War of 1861, most of these German revolutionaries were living in St. Louis and were known as "Wide-Awakes," in a modern day sense, illegal immigrants, speaking a foreign language, who admired Mr. Lincoln's ideals. Mr. Lincoln, in return utilised them for his own revolution, one masked by the popular moral cause of ending slavery, but in reality ending states' rights.

Missouri's legally elected government was overthrown at gunpoint by General Lyon who vowed to kill every man, women and child rather than let Missouri secede.

But Missouri's truly elected legislature reconvened in Neosho, Missouri in October, 1861 and passed an ordinance of secession. There was a quorum in the Senate and the House, and it was recognised by the Confederate Congress in November, 1861.

The next time someone tells you that Missouri was a "Northern" state ask them why Abraham Lincoln was forced to keep one-fourth of the Union Army in Missouri in an attempt to control the population?

Sectional differences remain today in Missouri. Most of those who hold German ancestry remain in the "Missouri-Rhineland", an island among Southerners. History however, is written in "blue ink" , the popular belief being that Missouri was a "Border State" with Southern sympathisers, the reality being that Missouri was a Southern State with pockets of Union sympathisers.

Missouri is still mainly an "agricultural" society with the two main exceptions being St. Louis and Kansas City and "Yankees" for the most part remain "islands" in a "sea of Southerners

Replies (10)

  • MoBush, Thanks for posting. Is the Semo link supposed to open to more?

    -- Posted by Old John on Mon, Jul 18, 2011, at 1:29 PM
  • John, the semo link is a link to James Baughn's post about Belmont, Mo.

    -- Posted by mobushwhacker on Mon, Jul 18, 2011, at 7:08 PM
  • mobush, I couldn't get that link to work.

    -- Posted by Old John on Mon, Jul 18, 2011, at 7:19 PM
  • Old John,

    Although the link does not work it is a simple matter to go to southernnationalist.com and find the article. There are several interesting articles. Thank you, mobush!

    -- Posted by Robert* on Mon, Jul 18, 2011, at 8:10 PM
  • Copy the link from the post and past it to your brouser... it will work then, or did for me.

    -- Posted by Have_Wheels_Will_Travel on Mon, Jul 18, 2011, at 8:18 PM
  • Mobush, thank you for your interesting and informative posts. They are always a pleasure to read.

    -- Posted by voyager on Tue, Jul 19, 2011, at 7:40 AM
  • Thanks MOBush

    -- Posted by Joe Dirte on Tue, Jul 19, 2011, at 8:16 AM
  • MOBUSH: With all the "hype", at least once each year, about the "venerable"-Fort D in Cape---isn't there still an existing rock-based structure in Jackson, that was/is a former CONFEDERATE-outpost? I'm thinking it's been re-worked, of course, into a residence, for as long as I can remember?

    Cape may have been BLUE---but one didn't have to go far outside of same, to find a rather-large "pockets" of GREY, for sure.

    Your posting ties-in well, with the history of the original-Bollinger Mill, as well.

    Nothin' "political", or prejudice, about it---just the facts, is all...

    -- Posted by donknome-2 on Tue, Jul 19, 2011, at 8:21 AM
  • SPANK: Yeah, I know where you're speaking of, and that IS what they called it, "The Slave House". Not sure of it's origins, and not sure if it still stands or not.

    (Do you remember the name/now number, of the road? I'm also thinking of yet ANOTHER old-orchard house, just-off of D, to the EAST---I think "Turner-Orchard" homestead?) But I don't think it ever had chains/bars? It had a lotta BRICKS, though!

    But, the "Slave House" may have been a holding-area for prisoners/slaves/etc. I always wondered myself? Maybe someone on-here can enlighten us to the truth?

    (It'd be a good-project for JAMES BAUGHN to explore, if he can "hear" us???☺!)

    The particular-home I was thinking of as a Confederate-outpost, in Jackson-city, is the rock-house just behind/west of Jones Drug.(Missouri Street, maybe?) Don't remember if I'd heard such, or just imagined it, anymore?

    Either way, it sure LOOKS the part, true or not...!

    -- Posted by donknome-2 on Tue, Jul 19, 2011, at 12:21 PM
  • There are a number of slave houses in Ste Gen/St Francis county areas as well. One still stands near the Madison/St Francis county line next to the two story farmhouse built in the early 1800's. Another was a large brick two story building located right where the Crown Valley winery sits now. We used to play inside the building while visiting relatives as a kid, hated to see it torn down for a winery

    -- Posted by Joe Dirte on Tue, Jul 19, 2011, at 12:28 PM

Respond to this thread